Review: Skeleton Women by Mingmei Yip

Posted September 18, 2012 by in Book Reviews / 8 Comments

I received this book for free from the publisher / TLC Book Tours in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.

Review: Skeleton Women by Mingmei YipSkeleton Women by Mingmei Yip
Published by Kensington on May 2012
Genres: Fiction
Format: Paperback
Pages: 352
Source: the publisher / TLC Book Tours

Goodreads | Amazon

Once upon a time in China, the most beautiful and gifted women were known as "skeleton women"--the ultimate femmes fatales who could bring a man to his knees, or to his doom...

When Camilla, a young orphan girl in Shanghai, is adopted and brought to live in luxury, it seems like a stroke of luck. But as Camilla grows to womanhood, she realizes that her "rescue" was part of gang leader Big Brother Wang's scheme. Camilla is trained in singing, dancing, knife-throwing, and contortion--all to attract the attention of Wang's enemy, the ruthless Master Lung.

Forced to become Master Lung's mistress, Camilla meets two other intriguing women. Shadow is a magician and rival for Master Lung's affections, while Rainbow Chang dresses like a man and wields power through her incendiary gossip column. Both pose risks to Camilla's safety and status. But an even greater danger comes in the form of Master Lung's eldest son, Jinying, who despises his father's violent lifestyle--but loves Camilla. Only by plotting to eliminate Lung can she make her escape, but at what cost?

(from the inside flap)

In Skeleton Women, Camilla tells her story in the first-person point of view, using The Art of War by Sunzi and the Thirty-Six Stratagems as backdrops for the way she lives her life and the decisions she makes as a skeleton woman.

This book was both interesting and maddening: I thoroughly enjoyed reading about the parts of the Chinese culture that were focused on in the story, and I was really ticked off at the way the women were treated and pitted against one another. It’s really depressing to read about women who think their only worth comes from their beauty, their talents, or the way they can destroy one another through gossip. Camilla and Shadow really didn’t seem to have much of a choice, either–they both came from poor backgrounds and were forced to be dependent on other people for their livelihoods, although they didn’t end up much better off in the long run.

The plot was pretty good, although I’m not sure there was as much tension in it as Yip intended there to be. Being a spy in a dangerous enemy’s lair would be scary as hell, but I didn’t feel all that nervous about Camilla’s outcome for some reason. The possibility of Camilla’s death was written about numerous times throughout the story, but the feeling wasn’t there for me. Nevertheless, I still wanted to keep reading to find out whether or not Camilla would escape the hold both gangsters had on her.

I did have a lot of empathy for Camilla and Shadow when it came to their emotions, though. Both women had been trained–professionally and by their life circumstances–to compartmentalize their emotions. As a spy, Camilla couldn’t afford to fall in love with anyone for her own physical safety. Shadow couldn’t afford to fall in love with just anyone for her own financial safety. Both women had to use all of their energy to fight for status in a world where status means everything. Neither woman could afford to let her guard down for one minute and truly enjoy herself and her life. Their beauty and their talents weren’t going to last forever–everyone grows old eventually–so both women had to do what they could, in a relatively short amount of time, to guarantee that they would be okay in later years. The amount of stress they had to deal with was monumental. I can only imagine what it must feel like to live that way. There are other things that happened that made me feel terrible for Camilla and Shadow that I can’t mention without giving too much of the story away. Their stories were just heartbreaking.

Rainbow Chang was certainly an interesting character. Her gender and sexuality were ambiguous, and I liked that no one seemed to care. In this country, all kinds of things are said about people who don’t fit neatly into specific gender categories, but in Shanghai (at least in this story), no one made a big deal about Rainbow Chang at all. I don’t know enough about Chinese culture to know if this is more widely accepted there than in this country, or if Rainbow Chang was left alone because people were afraid of her taking them down in her gossip column. Whatever the reason, I loved that her lifestyle was generally accepted and not made a big deal of. Bravo.

While I didn’t necessarily feel a lot of suspense in Skeleton Women, and while I think a couple of parts of the plot should have been expanded upon, I enjoyed it quite a bit and I’m glad I read it. I like learning about other countries and cultures, and the ways in which people’s lives are different from mine–it helps me to better understand the world and it helps me to keep things in perspective. I’m definitely going to be looking into Mingmei Yip’s other books in the future.

Visit TLC Book Tours at


  • Sounds good. Shame about the lack of tension though!

    • It was very good aside from that, but the author may not have intended for there to be a lot of tension. I don’t know.

  • I always like a book set in another culture that is foreign to my own. Have you read anything by Lisa See? Her books are set in China, or in America with Chinese women, and I’ve loved almost everything I have read by her. If the Chinese culture calls to you, my favorites are “Snow Flower and the Secret Fan” and “Dreams of Joy.”

    • I bought Snow Flower and the Secret Fan for a friend years ago when it was first published. I’ve been meaning to read Lisa See’s books ever since then and just keep forgetting. I’ll have to write her name down on my author list and read her soon.

      • Snow Flower was such a good book! Very worthwhile read, and it inspired me to read others by See as well.

  • Pingback: Mingmei Yip, author of Skeleton Women, on tour September 2012 | TLC Book Tours()

  • I’m glad you enjoyed this overall, even if it didn’t end up being a favorite for you.

    Thanks for being on the tour.

  • Pingback: Reading Wrap-Up: September 2012 | Between the Covers()